Working towards the next version of the SWIM Supporting Material

Page tree

Working towards the next version of the SWIM Supporting Material

Skip to end of metadata
Go to start of metadata
Conformance assessment for the Donlon TOBT Setting Service Description.

Info

This is an example of use of the Conformance assessment report.




Object under Assessment

Donlon TOBT Setting Service Description, v0.93, 23/10/18.

Legend

Status 

The status column indicates conformance to the requirement, id est how far the requirement is satisfied. The identified status values are

symboldescription
(tick)requirement satisfied
(error)Mandatory requirement not satisfied
(thumbs down)Recommended requirement not satisfied

Note: in draft assessment reports, the status may include additional temporary values.

Reference 

The reference column indicates the location within the service description where the required information elements can be found. 

The location within this service description is rather obvious, as the sections mostly match the requirements in title and order. This information could thus have been omitted, but is made explicit to better convey the idea.

Comment

The comment column provides any additional useful information. This includes justification for not satisfying a requirement.

Overall assessment - NOT CONFORM

The service description is currently NOT CONFORM.

req countstatusstatus description
24(tick)requirement satisfied
3(error)Mandatory requirement not satisfied
2(thumbs down)Recommended requirement not satisfied

Detailed assessment

Conformance assesssment of each requirement from the specification.

Requirementlevelstatusreference / comment
General Requirements

 



SWIM-SERV-001 Description coverage

M

(tick)the description covers 1 service
SWIM-SERV-002 Description language

M

(tick)the description is in British English
SWIM-SERV-003 Define abbreviations

M

(tick)See Abbreviation section
SWIM-SERV-004 Use standard abbreviations

R

(tick)Except for a few acronyms related to projects (eg ACRIS, AACO and FT10) all acronyms are standard.
SWIM-SERV-005 Description identification

M

(tick)See Service Description Identification section.
SWIM-SERV-006 Service identification

M

(tick)See Service Identification section.
SWIM-SERV-007 Service abstract

M

(tick)See Service Abstract section.
SWIM-SERV-008 Service provider

M

(tick)See Service Provider section.
SWIM-SERV-009 Service categories

M

(tick)

See Service Categories section.

In addition to the required category on PCP information exchange area, the description uses the following Service Categorisation Scheme.

SWIM-SERV-010 Service standard reference

M

(tick)See Service standard reference section.
SWIM-SERV-011 Operational needs

M

(tick)See Operational Needs section. Including the IERs used to identify and design the service.
SWIM-SERV-012 Service functionality

M

(tick)See Service Functionality section
SWIM-SERV-013 Access and use conditions

M

(error)The Access and Use Conditions section is currently empty.
SWIM-SERV-014 Quality of service

M

(error)The Quality of Service section contains fake values.
SWIM-SERV-015 Technical constraint

M Cond

(tick)See Technical Constraint section.
Service Interface Requirements

 



SWIM-SERV-016 Service interfaces

M

(tick)See TOBTSettingReceiver Interface section.
SWIM-SERV-017 Message exchange pattern

M

(tick)See TOBTSettingReceiver Interface section.
SWIM-SERV-018 TI Profile and bindings

M

(tick)See SWIM TI Profile and interface bindings section
SWIM-SERV-019 Protocols and data format

M

(tick)See Service interface protocols and data format section
SWIM-SERV-020 Machine-readable interface

M Cond

(error)The Machine-readable service interface definition section is currently empty.
SWIM-SERV-021 Service operations

M

(tick)See Service Operations section.
SWIM-SERV-022 Information definition

M

(tick)see Information Definition section.
SWIM-SERV-023 AIRM conformance

M

(tick)See AIRM Conformance section.
SWIM-SERV-024 Filter capabilities

M

(tick)No Filtering capability.
SWIM-SERV-025 Service behaviour

M

(tick)See Service behaviour section.
SWIM-SERV-026 Model view

R

(thumbs down)The Model view section is currently empty.
Other Requirements

 



SWIM-SERV-027 Service validation

M

(tick)See Service validation section. (requirement satisfied even though no validation has been performed)
SWIM-SERV-028 Service monitoring

M Cond

(tick)See Service monitoring section.
SWIM-SERV-029 Examples of code

R

(thumbs down)The Example fo code section is currently empty.
  • No labels